When Chaos Tells a Story: An AI Creativity Experiment

For this experiment, I decided to hand the steering wheel to chance. I gave ChatGPT two random, unrelated images (both created by Midjourney) and five random words, words with no connection, rhyme or reason (words created by ChatGPT). Then I asked it to write a 200-word story that somehow pulled everything together. No hints. No context. Just chaos.

It’s the kind of challenge I’d struggle with myself. A jumble of words and pictures that don’t belong together, and yet, that’s what makes it irresistible. Could an AI find a thread of meaning where there shouldn’t be one?

The five random, unrelated words were: Velvet, Splinter, Compass, Jigsaw, Marshmallow

I then asked for two more random words and I got: Blueprint and Tangle. I used these two words, each as a single word prompt in Midjourney and these were the images created:

Then, back to ChatGPT. The prompt for the story was:

Create a 200-word story incorporating these two images and these 5 words – Velvet, Splinter, Compass, Jigsaw, Marshmallow

… and here is the story:

---

The Velvet Machine

They called it the Velvet Machine, though nothing about it was soft. It was built from blueprints older than memory, lines of ink and oil merging like veins. Within its chambers, wires pulsed like living roots, red, white, and black, braiding themselves into patterns that no human mind could decode.

Liora pressed her hand to the humming glass, feeling the faint heartbeat beneath. The compass on her wrist spun wildly, as though the machine distorted direction itself. Every engineer who’d tried to map it had failed; its workings were a jigsaw missing half its pieces.

Yet, something was growing. Tiny leaves, pink as marshmallows, sprouted from the twisted cords, trembling with breath. She watched in awe as the first tendril reached toward her, gentle as a child’s question.

Then came the splinter, a spark of light that cracked through her reflection. The machine pulsed once, twice, and stilled.

On the blueprint table, the ink began to shift. New lines unfurled themselves, forming her own face. Below it, in curling script, appeared a note:

“Every design becomes its maker.“

Liora didn’t move. The roots were already winding around her arm, finishing what she’d started.

---

What fascinates me most is that it works. Not perfectly, but convincingly enough to make me pause. Somehow, from fragments of randomness, a story appears, with atmosphere, emotion, even purpose.

How is this possible? AI is trained to detect patterns, it can’t help linking things together. Give it chaos, and it hunts for coherence. In that sense, it’s doing what we humans do every day: finding meaning in noise, shapes in clouds, faces in shadows.

Writers have always used randomness to unlock creativity. Think of the Surrealists and their “Exquisite Corpse” games, or the way a dream can spark a poem. The AI doesn’t feel creative, but it mimics the creative act, a reflection of our own need to make sense of things.

Perhaps that’s the real intrigue here. When AI spins stories from scattered clues, it mirrors our own imagination back at us, showing that the boundary between machine and mind isn’t as clear as we thought.

Maybe creativity isn’t about control. Maybe it’s about connection, between images, words, ideas, or even between human and machine.What do you think? Does creativity emerge from chaos, or is there something deeper that only we humans bring to the mix?

---

---